“An estate is a pond. A trade is a spring.”
— Robinson Crusoe
Survival, Providence, and the Long Return
First published in 1719, Robinson Crusoe blends spiritual reflection, survival narrative, and exotic adventure into what is often regarded as the first English-language novel. Despite some pacing and thematic problems in the second half, Crusoe remains a compelling journey of mind and body.
A Young Man Against His Father’s Wisdom
Crusoe, the privileged son of a merchant, rejects his father’s counsel to seek the “middle state” of life—moderate work, moderate comfort, far from poverty and excess. Instead, Crusoe craves the extreme life, an adventure at sea and abroad. Quickly, the young man encounters the destructive power of nature, the depravity of man, and a before-unfathomable spiritual isolation. In his first voyage, he gets seasick and nearly is thrown overboard. A second voyage takes him to Africa, where he’s captured by Barbary pirates and enslaved. His daring escape with the boy Xury brings him face to face with lions, cannibalistic savages, and finally a merchant ship that promises to carry him to safety.
Shipwreck
On this third voyage, Crusoe is shipwrecked on a deserted island. He is the lone survivor. October 1 marks his “first day,” as he is physically and spiritually a newborn. His will to survive is desperate and he tackles the task of food and shelter methodically. He salvages gunpowder, tools, and seeds. He builds a tent, then a fortified cave, whose location he chooses for three reasons: for a view of passing ships, for safety from predators, and shelter from rain.
In subsequent journal entries, he charts his survival and his spiritual reckoning. Illness nearly kills him, and a vivid vision drives him to repent to God for his sinful preceding life. As he heals, his gratitude grows for his circumstances—for the European barley sprouting near his cave one morning, for the divine mercy of other provisions, for the breath in his lungs.
Solitude
Years pass. Crusoe learns agriculture—reaping and sowing barley, corn, wheat—by trial and error. He domesticates goats, bakes bread, studies seasons. He explores nearby islands, but fears encountering savages, with which there is no communication except for violence. The discovery of a single footprint shatters his sense of safety, and later he finds bones and ash from cannibal feasts.
After 25 years, he rescues a captive from such a feast—naming him Friday, for the day he rescued him on. Crusoe teaches him English, Christian morals, and “civilized” ways of thinking and being. Together they free other captives, fight off attackers, and aid shipwrecked sailors.
The Return
Eventually, Crusoe leaves the island to help retake a mutinied ship, promising his home and the buried treasure he has accumulated to those who help him. After 28 years, he returns to England. There he tends to family affairs and also his Brazilian plantation, which he had established before his shipwreck. Then, curiously, the novel drifts into a wintry trek through France, during which Crusoe fends off wolves with his musket, before ending the tale with the promise of even more adventures.
Overall
The first half of Robinson Crusoe surprised me with its powerful, personal, philosophical meditations. As I read the yearning of young Crusoe for an adventure at sea and experienced his heartbreaking captivity by Barbary pirates, his ingenious emancipation, and tragic shipwreck onto the island, I greatly appreciated most Crusoe's internal dilemmas. He wrestles with God, cursing his physical and spiritual isolation. Upon many years of toil on-island and honest self-reflection, he celebrates his victories over the sea, bouts of bad health, his escape from and evasion of cannibals, and from the constant threats of famine. This transformation from victimhood to a kind of stoic gratitude, is earnest and enthralling.
As mentioned above, I do feel that that the second half loses a chronological focus, which in turn scatters the novel's thematic power. There’s no reunion with his father and mother, nor is there a climactic spiritual awakening with God, whom he communes with in his diary and daily prayers. Non-essential affairs are wrapped up succinctly in a kind of travel-journal form, a form different and less dramatic than the novel's initial aim. Still, Crusoe’s adventure on the island remains a compelling, personal quest: a transformation from sin and folly by means of hard work and self-reflection, to arrive at a foundation of gratitude and salvation. [JG]
First published in 1719, Robinson Crusoe blends spiritual reflection, survival narrative, and exotic adventure into what is often regarded as the first English-language novel. Despite some pacing and thematic problems in the second half, Crusoe remains a compelling journey of mind and body.
A Young Man Against His Father’s Wisdom
Crusoe, the privileged son of a merchant, rejects his father’s counsel to seek the “middle state” of life—moderate work, moderate comfort, far from poverty and excess. Instead, Crusoe craves the extreme life, an adventure at sea and abroad. Quickly, the young man encounters the destructive power of nature, the depravity of man, and a before-unfathomable spiritual isolation. In his first voyage, he gets seasick and nearly is thrown overboard. A second voyage takes him to Africa, where he’s captured by Barbary pirates and enslaved. His daring escape with the boy Xury brings him face to face with lions, cannibalistic savages, and finally a merchant ship that promises to carry him to safety.
Shipwreck
On this third voyage, Crusoe is shipwrecked on a deserted island. He is the lone survivor. October 1 marks his “first day,” as he is physically and spiritually a newborn. His will to survive is desperate and he tackles the task of food and shelter methodically. He salvages gunpowder, tools, and seeds. He builds a tent, then a fortified cave, whose location he chooses for three reasons: for a view of passing ships, for safety from predators, and shelter from rain.
In subsequent journal entries, he charts his survival and his spiritual reckoning. Illness nearly kills him, and a vivid vision drives him to repent to God for his sinful preceding life. As he heals, his gratitude grows for his circumstances—for the European barley sprouting near his cave one morning, for the divine mercy of other provisions, for the breath in his lungs.
Solitude
Years pass. Crusoe learns agriculture—reaping and sowing barley, corn, wheat—by trial and error. He domesticates goats, bakes bread, studies seasons. He explores nearby islands, but fears encountering savages, with which there is no communication except for violence. The discovery of a single footprint shatters his sense of safety, and later he finds bones and ash from cannibal feasts.
After 25 years, he rescues a captive from such a feast—naming him Friday, for the day he rescued him on. Crusoe teaches him English, Christian morals, and “civilized” ways of thinking and being. Together they free other captives, fight off attackers, and aid shipwrecked sailors.
The Return
Eventually, Crusoe leaves the island to help retake a mutinied ship, promising his home and the buried treasure he has accumulated to those who help him. After 28 years, he returns to England. There he tends to family affairs and also his Brazilian plantation, which he had established before his shipwreck. Then, curiously, the novel drifts into a wintry trek through France, during which Crusoe fends off wolves with his musket, before ending the tale with the promise of even more adventures.
Overall
The first half of Robinson Crusoe surprised me with its powerful, personal, philosophical meditations. As I read the yearning of young Crusoe for an adventure at sea and experienced his heartbreaking captivity by Barbary pirates, his ingenious emancipation, and tragic shipwreck onto the island, I greatly appreciated most Crusoe's internal dilemmas. He wrestles with God, cursing his physical and spiritual isolation. Upon many years of toil on-island and honest self-reflection, he celebrates his victories over the sea, bouts of bad health, his escape from and evasion of cannibals, and from the constant threats of famine. This transformation from victimhood to a kind of stoic gratitude, is earnest and enthralling.
As mentioned above, I do feel that that the second half loses a chronological focus, which in turn scatters the novel's thematic power. There’s no reunion with his father and mother, nor is there a climactic spiritual awakening with God, whom he communes with in his diary and daily prayers. Non-essential affairs are wrapped up succinctly in a kind of travel-journal form, a form different and less dramatic than the novel's initial aim. Still, Crusoe’s adventure on the island remains a compelling, personal quest: a transformation from sin and folly by means of hard work and self-reflection, to arrive at a foundation of gratitude and salvation. [JG]
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
 AN ILLUSTRATED BOOK OF BAD ARGUMENTS Ali Almossawi  MYTHOLOGY Edith Hamilton |  THE FORK, THE WITCH, AND THE WORM Christopher Paolini  READY PLAYER ONE Ernest Cline |
